We publish our audit record because accuracy claims should be checkable. Every entry on this site runs through an automated fact-audit pipeline (accuracy audit → source-grounded repair → visual QA); this page is generated from that pipeline's own report, not written by hand.
Last full accuracy audit: 2026-09-07 · 39 entries checked · 17 flagged · 44 issues confirmed · 0 corrected · 44 still open
The Gate of Worlds — The protagonist Dan Beauchamp is 17 years old, not 18.
The Gate of Worlds — The novel's alternate timeline year is not explicitly given as 1967 in the text.
Hawksbill Station — The novel expands upon a novella titled 'Hawksbill Station' that first appeared in the July 1967 issue of Galaxy Science Fiction, not a short story; the August 1967 issue contained a different Silverberg story, 'The Shadow of Wings'.
Hawksbill Station — The character Jacob 'Jack' Bernstein is not the de facto leader of the colony; the de facto leader is Lew Hahn.
Kingdoms of the Wall — The novel was published in 1992, but it was actually published in 1991.
Kingdoms of the Wall — The entry says 'the gods are actually a degenerate human colony' — this is incorrect; the gods are revealed to be degenerate descendants of the original human colonists, not a human colony itself.
Lord Valentine's Castle — The entry states that the Lady of the Isle of Dreams is always the Coronal's mother, but in canon this is only true for the current Coronal in this specific story, not a fixed general rule.
Lord Valentine's Castle — The entry oversimplifies the King of Dreams' role by stating he dispatches nightmares 'to keep order', whereas his role is more complex in canon.
Majipoor series — The King of Dreams role is not created at the end of *King of Dreams*; it is an established power long before that novel's events.
Majipoor series — The statement that *Valentine Pontifex* ends with a fifth Power representing the Piurivar is incorrect; the four Powers remain throughout the main sequence.
The Positronic Man — The entry states the novel is set in 'Asimov's Foundation universe,' but 'The Positronic Man' and its source story 'The Bicentennial Man' are set in Asimov's Robot series/Empire universe, not the Foundation universe (though they are loosely connected via the o
The Positronic Man — The entry says 'Unlike most robots, which are leased by U.S. Robots and Mechanical Men, Andrew is owned outright.' In Asimov's canon, U.S. Robots typically sells robots, not leases them; the lease arrangement is not standard canon for the general robot market.
Revolt on Alpha C — The novel does not feature dinosaurs on the fourth planet of Alpha Centauri; the planet is described as having Earth-like life but not specifically dinosaurs.
Revolt on Alpha C — The entry states the ship travels '4.5 light-years to Alpha Centauri in 15 days using faster-than-light overdrive' — the distance to Alpha Centauri is approximately 4.37 light-years, not 4.5.
Roma Eterna — The claim that six stories appeared in Asimov's Science Fiction is incorrect; the actual count is five.
Roma Eterna — The claim that five stories were nominated for the Sidewise Award is incorrect; only four were nominated.
All content is fetchable as JSON at /data/content/ · llms.txt · sitemap
Spotted an error? Suggest an edit — reader reports go straight into the audit queue.